The Debate Over AI Tools and Voice Cloning
The use of AI tools has sparked a controversial debate, especially in industries where it involves reconfiguring someone’s work without their permission. One recent incident involving voice actor Amelia Tyler, known for her work in “Baldur’s Gate 3,” has highlighted the growing concern surrounding AI voice cloning.
Amelia Tyler expressed her anger and frustration after discovering that her voice was being used without her consent in AI-generated content. She came across a stream where she heard her own voice narrating explicit and disturbing content. Tyler denounced the unauthorized use of her voice and labeled it as a theft of both her job and her identity. She even urged for legislation to make such practices illegal.
Unfortunately, Amelia Tyler is not alone in experiencing this issue. Another voice actor, Allegra Clark, who voiced Beidou in “Genshin Impact,” also found her voice being used in sexually explicit content on TikTok. This incident raised concerns not only about the inappropriate content but also about the potential violation of Clark’s contracts.
The gray area surrounding the use of AI tools presents a significant challenge for voice actors like Tyler and Clark to contest the unauthorized use of their voices. While efforts have been made, such as the agreement between SAG-AFTRA and Replica Studios, which mandates compensation for actors whose voices are used in AI-generated content, there are still concerns. Some actors claim that they are already losing job opportunities to AI systems, while AI companies continue to thrive.
Neil Newbon, the actor behind Astarion in “Baldur’s Gate 3,” expressed his belief that programming cannot replicate the artistic craft and magic that actors bring to their performances. He emphasized that there is something beyond algorithms and formulas that make acting truly special.
In conclusion, the issue of AI tools and voice cloning remains a contentious topic. The unauthorized use of voice actors’ voices raises ethical concerns and questions about intellectual property. As the use of AI tools continues to grow, striking a balance between innovation and protecting the rights of artists and performers is crucial.
ESN.GG is supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission.